Nine US retail and restaurant trade associations have filed lawsuits challenging federal banking rules that could prevent Illinois from restricting card processing fees on sales taxes and customer tips.
Nine US retail and restaurant trade associations have filed lawsuits against federal banking regulators over rules that could block an Illinois law restricting credit and debit card processing fees.
Discover B2B Marketing That Performs
Combine business intelligence and editorial excellence to reach engaged professionals across 36 leading media platforms.
The legal action, announced on 12 November 2026, challenges measures introduced by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA), two US federal banking regulators.
The measures affect Illinois’ Interchange Fee Prohibition Act, which aims to prohibit interchange fees on the sales tax and tip portions of card transactions.
The lawsuits were filed in a federal court in Washington, DC, by organisations including the National Retail Federation (NRF), the National Association of Convenience Stores and the National Grocers Association.
The associations argue that the regulators exceeded their legal powers and failed to follow the required public consultation procedures.
The dispute could have wider implications for US retailers, restaurants and other businesses seeking to reduce card payment processing costs.
Illinois law targets card processing fees
Illinois passed the Interchange Fee Prohibition Act in 2024, becoming the first US state to introduce legislation prohibiting interchange fees on sales taxes and tips included in card payments.
Interchange fees, commonly called swipe fees in the US, are charges paid by merchants when customers use credit or debit cards. The fees are generally collected through payment processing arrangements and paid to the banks that issue the cards.
The Illinois law aims to prevent businesses from paying these charges on money collected for governments and employees, rather than retained as revenue.
Originally scheduled to take effect on 1 July 2026, the legislation was delayed by one year following legal challenges. It is now due to take effect in July 2027.
According to the merchant associations, the law could save Illinois businesses and consumers an estimated $500m a year.
The groups argue that applying processing fees to taxes and tips increases retailers’ operating costs, even though businesses do not retain those payments.
Retailers challenge federal banking rules
The lawsuits centre on whether federal banking laws allow regulators to prevent individual US states from restricting interchange fees.
In February 2026, US District Judge Virginia Kendall rejected arguments from banks that the Illinois legislation was overridden by the National Bank Act.
The judge found that interchange fees are set by payment networks, including Visa and Mastercard, rather than directly by banks. As the networks are not banks, the court concluded that the relevant federal banking provisions did not prevent the Illinois law from applying.
Banks appealed the decision.
In April, the OCC issued an interim final rule stating that federal banking law prevents states from imposing such restrictions on nationally chartered banks, which operate under federal rather than state licences.
The US Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit subsequently returned the case to the district court for further consideration.
In June, Kendall ruled against the Illinois law, citing the OCC’s new rule.
The NCUA introduced a similar measure in June, addressing the application of federal credit union legislation to state restrictions on interchange fees.
In September, Kendall extended a court order blocking enforcement of the Illinois legislation to cover federally chartered credit unions.
Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul announced in October that he would appeal both rulings.
Merchants question regulators’ authority
The trade associations argue that neither the National Bank Act nor the Federal Credit Union Act gives federal regulators the power to prevent Illinois from restricting interchange fees set by payment networks.
Their challenge to the OCC maintains that the Illinois law regulates charges determined by card networks rather than banking activities themselves.
The associations also question how the federal rules were introduced.
They argue that the OCC and NCUA failed to comply with the Administrative Procedure Act, which generally requires US federal agencies to publish proposed regulations and allow public comments before adopting them.
The OCC introduced its measure as an interim final rule, allowing it to take effect without the usual consultation process beforehand.
The associations claim this denied retailers and other affected businesses an opportunity to comment before the rule took effect.
NRF senior vice-president and general counsel Marissa Bostick said: “This is about more than one state law.”
She questioned whether federal agencies should be able to override state legislation in ways that benefit banks and credit unions at the expense of merchants.
The lawsuits seek to overturn the contested regulatory measures.
Banks support consistent national rules
Federal banking regulators and industry organisations have argued that consistent nationwide rules are necessary for the US card payments system.
In April, the OCC warned that the Illinois legislation could create a complex regulatory environment for banks and payment networks, particularly if other states introduced different interchange fee restrictions.
The regulator maintained that nationally chartered banks have the right to receive interchange fees, even when the charges are determined by payment networks.
The NCUA took a similar position in June, stating that federally chartered credit unions can collect interchange fees under federal law.
Both regulators invited public comments after issuing their interim rules.
However, the merchant associations argue that consultation after implementation does not replace the procedures normally required before regulations take effect.
Card processing costs remain a concern
The lawsuits come amid wider disagreement over the cost of card payments for US businesses.
According to the merchant associations, credit and debit card interchange fees total nearly $200bn annually across the US.
The groups claim that US fees are around ten times higher than those charged in Europe. They also argue that merchants pass some of these costs on to consumers through higher retail prices.
The figures form part of the associations’ wider campaign for changes to the US card payments system.
FMI – The Food Industry Association president and chief executive Leslie G Sarasin said: “Grocers should not be charged swipe fees on sales tax and tips.”
She said these payments are passed on to governments and employees rather than retained as grocery business revenue.
National Grocers Association president and chief executive Greg Ferrara also highlighted the impact of processing costs on independent food retailers.
He said money spent on interchange fees could instead help keep grocery prices affordable, support employees and fund local business operations.
For restaurants, the dispute centres on processing fees charged on customer tips and sales taxes.
Restaurant Law Center executive director Robin Repass said these payments pass through restaurants to governments and employees, while operators must cover the associated processing costs.
She said the regulators’ intervention had deprived restaurant owners of an opportunity to defend their interests through the normal consultation process.
Nine trade associations join legal challenge
The lawsuits bring together organisations representing convenience stores, supermarkets, restaurants, fuel retailers and other businesses.
Alongside the NRF, the participating organisations are the Retail Industry Leaders Association’s Retail Litigation Center, FMI – The Food Industry Association, the National Restaurant Association’s Restaurant Law Center, the National Grocers Association, the Illinois Retail Merchants Association, the Illinois Fuel and Retail Association, the Illinois Restaurant Association and the National Association of Convenience Stores.
National Association of Convenience Stores general counsel Doug Kantor questioned whether the OCC and NCUA had the legal authority to introduce the contested rules.
Retail Litigation Center president Monica Welt argued that states should be able to protect merchants and consumers from excessive payment processing costs.
The lawsuits will test whether the regulators acted within their legal powers and followed the required procedures when introducing their rules.
For retailers operating in Illinois, the immediate issue is whether the state’s interchange fee restrictions can take effect as scheduled in July 2027.
The proceedings could also help determine how far other US states can go in regulating card processing charges when federal banking regulators argue that national legislation takes precedence.
