The British Retail Consortium (BRC) has urged the UK government to cut the cost of hiring young workers and expand apprenticeship opportunities following the publication of Alan Milburn's youth employment review.
The retail industry body welcomed proposals in the review, From a Welfare State to a Working State, published on 17 November 2026, to reduce employer National Insurance costs, introduce recruitment incentives and improve access to training and work experience.
The BRC said the UK retail sector lost 120,000 jobs between 2024 and 2026, while employment costs rose by £6.5bn ($8.6bn). It attributed the increase to higher employer National Insurance contributions (NICs) and above-inflation rises in the National Living Wage.
BRC chief executive Helen Dickinson described the review as "a call to action to address a moral as well as an economic crisis".
She said helping young people prepare for employment would have limited impact unless businesses could afford to recruit them.
"Preparing young people for work is only half the answer. The other half is making sure there are jobs for them to go to and that requires reducing the cost of employment," Dickinson said.
Retailers seek lower National Insurance costs
The BRC supports Milburn's recommendation to gradually raise the earnings threshold at which employers begin paying National Insurance for workers aged 21 to 24 in retail and hospitality.
Under the proposal, the threshold would double from £5,000 to £10,000 over five years, subject to government finances.
The change would reduce the cost of employing younger workers, particularly in entry-level and part-time positions.
Dickinson described the recommendation as "not only incredibly welcome, but essential" and urged ministers to act quickly.
Retail is a major source of first jobs in the UK. According to the BRC, one in five people begin their working lives in the sector.
However, the industry body argues that rising employment costs are making it harder for retailers to recruit people with little or no previous work experience.
BRC backs separate youth minimum wage rates
The BRC also supports retaining lower statutory minimum wage rates for younger workers, arguing that they help inexperienced applicants compete for entry-level jobs.
The UK's minimum wage system sets different pay rates according to age and apprenticeship status. The government plans to gradually bring the minimum wage for 18-to-20-year-olds into line with the adult National Living Wage.
Milburn's review recommends considering the potential impact on youth employment when deciding how quickly to align the rates.
The BRC believes removing the difference too quickly could make employers less willing to recruit younger applicants.
"Young people with little or no experience already face an uphill battle competing with more experienced candidates," Dickinson said.
The organisation argues that businesses may favour experienced applicants if the cost of employing them becomes similar to that of recruiting and training younger workers.
Employment rights reforms raise concerns
The BRC has also urged caution over the implementation of the Employment Rights Act 2025, particularly measures concerning guaranteed working hours.
The legislation aims to strengthen employment protections, including giving workers on variable-hours contracts greater certainty over their working arrangements.
However, retailers are concerned that additional requirements could discourage recruitment for seasonal, temporary and entry-level positions.
The Milburn review recommends a cautious approach to implementing guaranteed-hours reforms, taking account of their potential impact on youth employment.
Dickinson said employment rules should protect workers without making businesses less willing to create jobs.
The BRC supports considering the effects of new employment regulations on recruitment opportunities, particularly for people entering the workforce.
Apprenticeship funding proposals draw criticism
The BRC has criticised a recommendation to reduce government funding for apprenticeship training for people aged over 25, warning that it could increase costs for employers.
Under the proposal, government support for these apprenticeships would fall by 25%.
The industry body said retailers already contribute hundreds of millions of pounds through the Growth and Skills Levy, a system used to fund workforce training, but access only around half of the funding available to them.
It argues that increasing employers' contributions towards apprenticeship costs could discourage investment in existing staff.
"It makes little sense to invest in getting a 24-year-old into work, only to make their continued development into better-paid, higher-skilled jobs even more expensive the moment they turn 25," Dickinson said.
The BRC wants employers to have greater flexibility over how they use levy funds. It also wants unused contributions to remain available for apprenticeships and workforce development rather than returning to the Treasury.
Retailers support more youth apprenticeships
Despite its concerns about funding for older apprentices, the BRC backs Milburn's ambition to double apprenticeship numbers among people under 25.
The review recommends increasing the employer incentive for recruiting a new apprentice aged 16 to 24 from £2,000 to £2,500. It also proposes extending the payment to businesses that contribute to the Growth and Skills Levy.
A separate £2,000 payment for apprenticeship training providers is also proposed.
The BRC welcomed plans for pre-apprenticeship courses to help young people develop workplace skills before entering formal training.
It also wants apprenticeship programmes to reflect changing skills needs in retail, including artificial intelligence (AI) and climate resilience.
Dickinson stressed that training should help young people progress into better-paid, higher-skilled roles rather than focusing only on their first job.
The BRC argues that achieving this will require more flexible apprenticeship funding and training programmes that meet employers' needs.
Hiring incentives could encourage recruitment
Milburn's review also proposes expanding financial support for employers that recruit young people who face difficulties entering the labour market.
One recommendation would expand the Youth Jobs Grant to provide payments of up to £7,000 for businesses hiring eligible people aged 16 to 24 who have been outside education, employment or training for at least six months.
The proposed maximum includes a £3,000 core grant, with additional support for employers recruiting young people facing significant barriers to employment and, where applicable, smaller businesses.
The review also recommends raising the incentive for recruiting apprentices aged 16 to 24 to £2,500 and making it available to levy-paying employers.
The BRC supports these proposals, arguing that financial incentives could help businesses manage the cost of taking on inexperienced workers.
Dickinson said the measures "could make a real difference to employers looking to create opportunities for young people".
She also called for simple application and payment processes, particularly for large retailers recruiting substantial numbers of employees.
Work experience offers another route into retail
The BRC has highlighted work experience as an important way to help young people secure their first jobs.
It pointed to Opening Shift, an initiative developed with government involvement that brings together retailers to offer thousands of work experience placements.
The programme aims to give participants practical workplace experience and improve their chances of finding employment.
Dickinson described work experience as "a vital bridge into employment", particularly for applicants who struggle to find work because they lack previous experience.
The BRC also welcomed Milburn's proposed Youth Opportunity Test, which would assess how government policies affect employment prospects for young people.
The measure is intended to help policymakers identify regulations or other decisions that could unintentionally discourage businesses from recruiting younger workers.
Government outlines response to Milburn review
Milburn's independent review was commissioned by the Department for Work and Pensions to examine the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training, commonly described as NEET.
The report proposes a ten-year programme of reforms covering employment, education, skills, health and welfare support.
It estimates that implementing its recommendations in full could increase UK gross domestic product (GDP) by approximately 0.4% a year by 2036.
Responding to the report in Parliament on 17 November, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden backed the need for a new approach to youth employment.
The government accepted the central principles of an Opportunity and Support Guarantee, intended to help young people access education, training, apprenticeships, work experience or employment through more personalised local services.
It also announced a Youth Opportunities Unit to coordinate work across government.
The government confirmed plans to extend its Jobs Guarantee to young people who have received Universal Credit, a UK welfare benefit, for 12 months rather than the existing 18-month qualifying period.
McFadden said a White Paper setting out the government's proposals would be published in early 2027, with legislation to follow.
However, ministers have not committed to adopting every recommendation in the Milburn review. Further decisions will take account of a separate review of Personal Independence Payment, a disability benefit.
For retailers, the government's next steps will determine whether proposals to reduce National Insurance costs, reform apprenticeship funding and expand recruitment incentives become policy.
The BRC maintains that lower hiring costs, more accessible training and continued opportunities for inexperienced workers are necessary if retail is to play a greater role in reducing youth unemployment.


